The Best Burger Toppings to Try at Burger in the Square

Mark Austin • February 28, 2025

The Best Burger Toppings to Try at Burger in the Square

A row of palm trees against a blue sky

When it comes to crafting the perfect burger, the toppings you choose can make all the difference. At Burger in the Square, we take pride in offering a variety of fresh, flavorful toppings that allow you to customize your burger just the way you like it. Whether you're a fan of classic ingredients or love to experiment with bold flavors, here are some of the best burger toppings to try on your next visit.

1. Classic Favorites

If you're a traditionalist, you can't go wrong with these tried-and-true toppings:

  • Crisp Lettuce & Juicy Tomatoes – A fresh crunch and a bit of acidity balance the richness of the beef.
  • Onions (Grilled or Raw) – Add a bit of bite with raw onions or a touch of sweetness with caramelized onions.
  • Pickles – The perfect tangy contrast to a juicy patty.
  • Cheese (American, Cheddar, Swiss, or Pepper Jack) – A gooey, melty layer of cheese makes any burger better.

2. Premium Toppings for an Extra Kick

Want to take your burger to the next level? Try these premium options:

  • Bacon – Smoky, crispy, and delicious—bacon makes everything better.
  • Avocado or Guacamole – Creamy and packed with flavor, avocado adds a fresh touch.
  • Fried Egg – A runny yolk creates an extra level of richness.
  • Jalapeños or Hot Sauce – Perfect for those who love a little heat.

3. Specialty and Unique Toppings

For a one-of-a-kind burger experience, experiment with these unexpected but delicious toppings:

  • Pineapple – A touch of sweetness that pairs surprisingly well with a savory burger.
  • BBQ Sauce – Smoky, tangy, and just the right amount of sweet.
  • Coleslaw – A crunchy, creamy topping that adds texture and flavor.
  • Mushrooms – Sauteed mushrooms provide an earthy umami flavor that complements beef beautifully.

4. Build Your Ultimate Burger

At Burger in the Square, we encourage creativity! Mix and match toppings to create your ultimate burger combination. Whether you go with a classic cheeseburger or a gourmet creation with avocado, fried egg, and jalapeños, we’ve got all the ingredients to make it happen.

Next time you're craving a burger in Roanoke, stop by Burger in the Square and try out these delicious toppings. No matter your preference, we have something to satisfy your taste buds. What’s your favorite burger topping? Let us know in the comments below!

By Mark Austin September 9, 2025
The Flavor Story Behind Roanoke’s Favorite Burger Spot
By Mark Austin September 5, 2025
Why Burger in the Square Has Been a Roanoke Favorite Since 1984
By Mark Austin August 28, 2025
Why Burger In The Square is Roanoke’s Go-To Spot Since 1984
Hamburger on a bun with a grilled patty and melted cheese, on a white paper.
By Mark Austin August 21, 2025
Why Fresh Ingredients Make the Best Burgers in Roanoke
Hamburger with jalapeƱos and cream cheese on a white surface.
By Mark Austin August 16, 2025
The Secret to a Great Burger: Fresh Ingredients and Local Flavor
Hamburger with pretzel bun and toppings on a paper liner.
By Mark Austin August 14, 2025
Why Fresh Ingredients Make the Best Burgers in Roanoke
A gloved hand holds a burger with a bun, patty, salsa, and lettuce on a paper-lined tray.
By Mark Austin August 11, 2025
Why Our Burgers Taste Better Than the Rest in Roanoke
Burger with a patty, topped with jalapeƱo slices, on a bun with spread on the top half.
By Mark Austin August 7, 2025
From Grill to Glory: Why Burger In The Square Is a Roanoke Favorite
A hamburger with lettuce tomato and cheese on a bun
By Mark Austin August 4, 2025
Crafting the Perfect Burger: From Patty to Bun
A person wearing gloves is holding a hamburger in their hand
By Mark Austin August 2, 2025
A Roanoke Tradition: Fresh Burgers Made Your Way